Sunday Dinner Creamy Chicken Sandwiches

When you live in the in-between places of a mid-western state like Ohio you attend a lot of pot-luck dinners. Church, birthdays, graduations, funerals, holidays, Boy Scouts, almost any gathering had the potential to be a pot-luck dinner. After you attend a few hundred of these you learn a few things like what you can bring to feed a crowd without spending a fortune or working all day to prepare. You also learn what to avoid (anything with pepperoni sprinkled on top).

I got this creamy chicken sandwich recipe at a church dinner many years ago. Someone else brought it and everyone was raving about it so I made sure to get the recipe. The lady that brought it smiled and said it isn’t really much of a recipe, but she freely shared the secret.

Before I let you in on this little secret, I’ll tell you this. These chicken sandwiches will be a hit at your house or any carry-in dinner. This recipe as is easily feeds 10-12 people. We make it at home and then eat leftovers for a couple of days with no complaints. If you need to feed an army double this recipe and buy lots of buns.

[Rich_Web_Slider id=”5″]

Sunday Dinner Creamy Chicken Sandwiches

Sunday Dinner Creamy Chicken Sandwiches
Rate this recipe
415 ratings
Save Recipe Save to BigOven

These are creamy and delicious shredded chicken sandwiches. This recipe holds well in a crock pot / slow cooker so they are perfect for carry in dinners, graduation parties, etc.

  • 36 oz Canned chunk chicken* with broth from can(s) – I use three 12 oz cans
  • 10.5 oz Can condensed cream of celery soup
  • 10.5 oz Can condensed cream of chicken soup
  • 6 oz Box instant chicken stuffing mix
  • 1 Cup hot water
  • 12 Hamburger Buns

  1. Put the canned chicken and the broth from the can(s) into a crock pot/slow cooker.
  2. Use a large spoon or fork to break up any large chunks and spread out the chicken.
  3. Add both cans of soup
  4. Add the entire box of instant stuffing mix and one cup of hot water
  5. Stir well to mix all ingredients
  6. Cook on low in the slow cooker for 3-4 hours or on high for one hour
  7. Spoon onto sandwich buns or bread and enjoy.

The nutrition facts assume you are using regular soup and stuffing. You can dramatically reduce the sodium by using low salt/sodium soup and stuffing mix. They still taste just as good but you get considerably less sodium.

Prep Time: 5 minutes Cook Time: 1 hour Yield: 12 Sandwiches
Serving Size: 1 Sandwich
Calories per serving: 244.56 kcal
Fat per serving: 4.91 g
Saturated fat per serving: 1.27 g
Carbs per serving: 41.6 g
Protein per serving: 7.79 g
Fiber per serving: 1.74 g
Sugar per serving: 4.83 g
Sodium per serving: 792.66 mg
Cholesterol per serving: 4.34 mg
Nutrition label for Sunday Dinner Creamy Chicken Sandwiches

The pictures really don’t do it justice. Everything blends together to create a rich, creamy chicken sandwich filling. The kids love it. Old people love it. It’s just really, really good. If you are feeding a large crowd and want some variety, make up a batch of my Sloppy Joe and you will have a real feast.

• This recipe is very forgiving. I’ve made it with two cans of cream of chicken when I didn’t have cream of celery soup on hand and everyone still ate it happily.
• If you don’t want to use canned chicken you can cook 2 lbs of chicken breasts or chicken tenderloins in one cup of water or chicken broth in a crock pot/slow cooker or instant pot and shred it. Use that plus the broth from cooking in place of the canned chicken
• If you are in a real hurry or don’t have a slow cooker you can use this recipe on the stove top in a large pot. Just mix all the ingredients and heat over medium flame until everything is hot and the stuffing has softened, about 15-20 minutes.

If you enjoyed this recipe and would like to support my efforts to share easy recipes with clear directions and pictures please consider stopping by my Pampered Chef Independent Consultant store. We offer just about anything you could want or need in the kitchen, and proceeds support my efforts to maintain the Old Guy Kitchen blog and other social media sites.

If you found this recipe helpful or have any questions or comments please feel free to use the comments section below.  If you want to see more good stuff from the Old Guy In The Kitchen click the “follow” here on the blog or visit my other sites:


2 thoughts on “Sunday Dinner Creamy Chicken Sandwiches

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.